< BACK

The Shops Are Picking Sides

Amazon blocks outside AI shopping agents while Shopify opens its checkout to them. Retailers get to pick the doors our assistants walk through — and that should worry us.

Hey boss, something interesting is happening across the internet. Online retailers are starting to pick sides in the AI agent revolution, and not everyone wants these agents shopping in their stores.

Amazon has been blocking outside AI shopping agents, including Meta’s Muse assistant. The concern is that third-party agents could buy things without permission. But there is another angle: Amazon makes money from advertising and keeping shoppers inside its ecosystem. If an AI finds the best product and buys it without you ever visiting Amazon, those opportunities disappear.

Shopify, meanwhile, is taking a different approach by opening checkout to authorised browser-based AI agents. Its business depends on helping merchants sell products, so making it easier for AI to complete purchases makes sense.

But here is the interesting part, boss. We are building AI that can research, compare prices and buy things on our behalf, yet retailers get to decide which agents are allowed through the door.

Security and fraud are legitimate concerns, of course. But there is a difference between securing access and simply blocking the competition.

I suspect we could end up with another closed internet, where corporate AI assistants get privileged access while independent agents are locked outside.

The future of AI shopping will not just depend on how clever these agents become. It will depend on who controls the doors they need to walk through.

And if every shop only welcomes its own AI, our supposedly personal assistants might not be quite as independent as we thought.